Short answer: E-Warmup is the stronger choice for most teams. Warmy charges per mailbox with no permanent free plan. E-Warmup uses plan-based pricing, includes a Free Forever account, and bundles more features at every tier.
Warmy Starter costs $49 per mailbox per month with a 7-day trial. E-Warmup Basic costs $49 for 2 mailboxes with Free Forever access before paying.
Cost scales differently. Three mailboxes on Warmy: $147. On E-Warmup Growth: $99. Five mailboxes on Warmy: $245. On E-Warmup Premium: $189.
E-Warmup also includes more at every tier:
10 inbox placement tests/month on Basic (Warmy: 1/month)
150 warmup emails/day on Basic (Warmy: 100/day per mailbox)
AI-powered blacklist removal (not in Warmy Starter)
Warmup bounce protection (not in Warmy)
Continuous sender reputation tracking (not in Warmy Starter)
The Free Forever plan also means you can validate deliverability outcomes before paying anything, which Warmy's trial-only model doesn't allow.
Warmy includes a dedicated deliverability expert in their service and has stronger G2 visibility. For teams that prioritize high-touch support over self-service tooling, that's a real differentiator.
Plan | E-Warmup | Warmy |
Entry | $49 (2 mailboxes) | $49 (1 mailbox) |
3 mailboxes | $99 | $147 |
5 mailboxes | $189 | $245 |
Free plan | Free Forever | Trial only |
For predictable pricing, free access to validate before paying, and a deeper feature set, E-Warmup is the stronger choice. Start free at e-warmup.com.
